New Baby Gifts

86 products

    Celebrate the arrival of a new bundle of joy with a truly special and personalized gift from Susabella. Our collection features heartwarming keepsakes that capture the magic of this precious moment. Many of our items can be customized with the baby's name or birthdate, creating a unique treasure that will be cherished for years to come. From adorable holiday ornaments that commemorate their first Christmas to charming nursery signs and personalized piggy banks that encourage early savings, Susabella offers a thoughtful selection of gifts to welcome the newest member of the family.

    86 products
    Sale
    Personalized Baby's First Christmas Ornament
    Sale price $34.95 Regular price $46.60 Save 25%
    Sale
    Star Ornament, Small Star Initial Christmas Ornament, Letter Ornament
    from $8.95 Regular price $11.93 Save 25%
    Sale
    Elephant Ornament, Personalized Baby's First Christmas Ornament 2024
    Sale price $31.50 Regular price $42.00 Save 25%
    Sale
    Rocking Horse - Personalized Baby's First Christmas Ornament 2024
    Sale price $34.95 Regular price $46.60 Save 25%
    Sale
    Small Initial Christmas Ornament - READY TO SHIP
    from $8.95 Regular price $11.93 Save 25%
    Sale
    Heart Shaped Personalized Baby's First Christmas Ornament
    Sale price $34.95 Regular price $46.60 Save 25%
    Sale
    Tooth Fairy Jar, Tooth Fairy Box, Tooth Fairy Pillow, Personalized
    from $24.28 Regular price $32.37 Save 25%
    Sale
    Polar Bear - Personalized Baby's First Christmas Ornament 2024
    Sale price $34.95 Regular price $46.60 Save 25%
    Sale
    Personalized Letter Christmas Ornament, Initial Ornament
    from $8.95 Regular price $11.93 Save 25%
    Sale
    Personalized Bank - Baptism Gift, Baby Gift or First Communion Gift
    from $44.54 Regular price $59.39 Save 25%
    Sale
    Snowflake Ornament, Personalized Baby's First Christmas 2024
    Sale price $28.50 Regular price $33.27 Save 14%
    Sale
    Set of 2 Customized Christmas Ornaments with Names
    from $38.95 Regular price $51.93 Save 25%
    Sale
    Personalized Elephant Bank - Custom Bank with Name
    from $45.67 Regular price $60.89 Save 25%
    Sale
    Birth Flower Christmas Ornament, Birth Month Flower Ornament 2024
    Sale price $22.74 Regular price $30.32 Save 25%
    Sale
    Teddy Bear Ornament, Personalized Baby's First Christmas Ornament 2024
    Sale price $28.50 Regular price $33.25 Save 14%
    Sale
    Rocking Horse Ornament, Personalized Baby's First Christmas 2024
    Sale price $28.50 Regular price $33.27 Save 14%
    Sale
    Family of 4 Customized Star Christmas Ornaments
    from $49.50 Regular price $66.00 Save 25%
    Sale
    Monogramed Star First Christmas Ornament - 2024
    Sale price $32.90 Regular price $43.87 Save 25%
    Sale
    Tree Ornament, Personalized Baby's First Christmas Ornament
    Sale price $28.50 Regular price $33.31 Save 14%
    Sale
    Personalized Star Ornament, Baby's First Christmas Ornament 2024
    Sale price $28.50 Regular price $33.27 Save 14%
    Sale
    Airplane Ornament, Personalized Baby's First Christmas 2024
    Sale price $28.50 Regular price $33.31 Save 14%
    Sale
    Elephant Ornament, Personalized Baby's First Christmas 2024
    Sale price $28.50 Regular price $33.31 Save 14%
    Sale
    Whale Ornament, Personalized Baby's First Christmas Ornament
    Sale price $31.50 Regular price $42.00 Save 25%
    Sale
    Butterfly Ornament, Personalized Ornament 2024
    Sale price $28.50 Regular price $33.31 Save 14%